Major Comox development gets council’s blessing

Eleventh-hour motion to delay decision on Lorne Hotel site defeated

  • May. 21, 2015 5:00 p.m.

Artist's conception view from the corner of Comox Ave. and Port Augusta St.

Erin Haluschak

Record Staff

Despite an attempt by Coun. Hugh MacKinnon to reconfigure the building from five to four storeys, Comox council approved Wednesday the development of the Lorne Hotel project.

The project has been at the centre of public opinion for more than a year, and gained momentum from those both for and against the proposed five-storey building following a public hearing earlier this month.

Last fall, rezoning and development permit applications were given first and second reading by council for a five-storey mixed-use building – the first of its size in Comox.

The project would feature a pub/bistro on the first floor, and a variety of condos from 700 to 1,500 square feet on the remaining floors.

In late November, the town hosted a public open house for the proposed development where residents came out in droves to view the latest architectural drawings and ask questions to the project manager Shawn Vincent and architect Harry Whitfield.

As a result of the feedback and comments from the open house, Vincent addressed council in early April with the latest design changes for the commercial/resident building.

“I have heard from many they want the project to go forward, but many do not support the five storeys on that small lot size,” explained MacKinnon, who noted the building will be with the town for the next 40 to 50 years.

“Let’s give a little bit more time to get it right.”

He proposed a motion to ask the developers to return with a proposal that is four, rather than five floors, and to continue with the Comox By The Sea maritime theme and with historical reference to the Lorne.

It was supported by Coun. Barbara Price, who added she heard a variety of reasons from the public as to why the building should not proceed as proposed, including height, inappropriate design, too little parking and that it would forever change the rural look of the town.

“I supported the motion to change to the project. We do need to look at the public for their views,” she explained.

Both Couns. Marg Grant and Ken Grant opposed MacKinnon’s motion.

“There’s another point we need to consider – that we’ve had one application to build the Lorne. If in fact, we were to send out a message to future investors that well, yes, we’re open to business, but this is going to complicate the application, what kind of message does that give to future investors?” said Marg.

“You make it sound like we can just lop a storey off; it’s just a simple little tweak to a plan at the very ‘nth’ hour,” added Ken Grant.

“This is a major change to this building – this will send them back to re-plan and redesign the entire building. There’s no chance that these guys are going to go ahead if we’re going to do that. To bring this at this time, I think is wrong.”

MacKinnon argued in the sprit of compromise, it was important to consider feedback from the public hearing, and that in the past, council has made changes to projects following a public hearing.

Ken Grant replied while that has happened, changes have never been to a major portion of a project.

“Compromise will kill this project, and you’ll end up with a vacant lot. Compromise should have been brought forward way earlier in the process.”

Richard Kanigan, the town’s chief administrative officer confirmed if council did indeed vote in favour of the new motion, the project would require another public hearing because the change to the project would be significant.

Coun. Russ Arnott noted council was voted in to make hard decisions, and questioned if 45 years from now, if a five-storey building will be much of an issue.

“I didn’t get into this gig to have everybody like me. I’ll do my best. To sit here and try to appease everybody, we cannot do it. None of us here can do that, and I think that’s what we’re trying to do here.”

MacKinnon’s motion was defeated 4-2, with Price and MacKinnon voting in favour. Mayor Paul Ives was not  present for the vote or any previous discussions of the project due to a declared conflict of interest.

Comox Zoning Bylaw Amendment No.1791 and Comox Phased Development Agreement Bylaw No. 1792 for 1770 Comox Avenue passed third reading 4-2, with Couns. Arnott, Ken Grant, Marg Grant and Acting Mayor Maureen Swift voting in favour.

After the meeting, developer Shawn Vincent said he feels the project is going to be the centrepiece the community is hoping for.

“We’ve heard from a lot of people in the community and at the end of the day, we really have compromised. We’ve heard the concerns of the local people, but we’re not building a building not just for today, this is a building that is going to be there for 45, 50 years.”

He added if paperwork and planning goes smoothly over the summer, construction could begin in the fall.

photos@comoxvalleyrecord.com

 

 

 

 

Just Posted

VIDEO: Care-A-Van offers more than just care in a van

Mobile clinic brings medical and social services to the Valley’s most vulnerable

5 tips for talking to your kids about cannabis

Health officials recommend sharing a harm reduction-related message.

Comox Valley Regional District seeking input on development of Tsolum River Agricultural Watershed Plan

This fall, the Comox Valley Regional District (CVRD) is inviting the community… Continue reading

Lane closure in Courtenay at Lewis Centre

The City of Courtenay will be working on the water distribution system… Continue reading

Comox Valley’s Rainbow Youth Theatre hosting 30th birthday party

Join Rainbow Youth Theatre for a 30th anniversary celebration at the Sid… Continue reading

VIDEO: Rescued eagle released in Ucluelet

“I’m very confident that he’s going to make it. He’s done very well.”

Private marijuana stores should shut down, Mike Farnworth says

B.C. has approved 62 licences, but they still need local approval

Courtenay’s Dingwall Road to be temporarily closed for construction

Next week, the intersection of Dingwall Road and McQuillan Road will be… Continue reading

HPV vaccine does not lead to riskier sex among teen girls: UBC

Girls are less likely to have sex now than they were a decade ago

VIDEO: Rescued eagle released in Ucluelet

“I’m very confident that he’s going to make it. He’s done very well.”

Koreas agree to break ground on inter-Korean railroad

The rival Koreas are holding high-level talks Monday to discuss further engagement amid a global diplomatic push to resolve the nuclear standoff with North Korea.

Flash floods kill at least 7 people in southwest France

Flash floods have left several people dead in southwest France, with roads swept away and streams become raging torrents as the equivalent of several months of rain fell overnight, authorities said Monday.

Trump to visit Florida, Georgia; search ongoing for missing

The death toll from Michael’s destructive march from Florida to Virginia stood at 17.

Canadians widely unaware of accomplishments of famous women, poll suggests

A new poll suggests Canadians have a lot to learn about the accomplishments of some of the country’s most famous women.

Most Read