A multi-use trail is the only financially viable option for E&N Rail bed

Dear editor,

It’s my understanding that the Regional District of Nanaimo and the City of Nanaimo have put forth a motion supporting the Friends of Rails to Trails Vancouver Island initiative to convert the E&N Rail bed to a multi-use trail. The CVRD should also support this idea and introduce a similar motion.

Here are just some of the reasons why it makes sense.

Passenger service on the corridor stopped in 2011 and the corridor has continued to decay. There has been no outcry to restore the lost transportation almost no one used prior. Since my land abuts the track I can with confidence report there was never more than a few passengers in the car in either direction.

The ICF (Island Corridor Foundation) is in debt.

They owe the CIBC approximately $892,000 and they owe the Southern Railway $175,000.

This adds up to over $1 million. These are both callable and secured by the foundation’s assets so they either have to keep borrowing or sell off public assets. It is highly irresponsible of decision-makers to continue to put the corridor at risk in this way.

This is putting a publicly owned treasure in great jeopardy.

Even so, there are some who continue to romanticize about rail travel on the island without concern for the facts.

The existing rails cannot support light rail transit so even if passenger service was restored the speed at which the train travels would remain absurdly slow, there would be no increase in ridership. The existing tract would have to be replaced to offer high-speed travel. Even then, with the sheer number of uncontrolled crossings along the corridor, high-speed train travel is at best unrealistic.

Canadian Pacific Railway sold this corridor for a buck in 2006 and received a nice $38 million tax savings for their trouble.

Having worked for CP for many years I know they would not have turned over a valuable asset for a mere $38 million one-time tax credit.

How much would it cost to turn it into a viable rail transportation corridor? At least $1 billion – let’s be honest. Vancouver Island has neither the population, freight, or resources required to see this to fruition.

The idea that a train service could operate with a non-motorized trail right beside it is not even possible as there are dozens and dozens of sections where it has been deemed (by engineers) impractical to have a shared railway and trail.

A trail along this corridor would be such a boon to this island that it boggles the mind that there is so much resistance in the halls of decision makers.

Marie Gaudreau

Union Bay

Just Posted

Police officer hit by car, stabbed in Edmonton attack back on job

Const. Mike Chernyk, 48, returned to work Thursday

New connector now open in Courtenay

A new connection between Highway 19 and north Courtenay is now open.… Continue reading

COLUMN: Sharing Side by Side returns to the Comox Valley

Every senior has a story. But not everyone gets the chance to… Continue reading

Decision made on where buses will stop near hospital

The Comox Valley Regional District came to a verdict on where buses… Continue reading

Bidding farewell to St. Joseph’s Hospital

Open house Saturday to celebrate long history of care-giving

VIDEO: ‘Lyle the singing pig’ searching for home

SPCA say the pig is ‘not opera-ready’

Dorsett has 2 goals, assist in Canucks’ 4-2 win over Sabres

‘It was a real good hockey game by our group,’ Canucks coach Travis Green said.

Berry disappointed: Bear tries to eat fake fruit on woman’s door wreath

A Winnipeg woman has taken her berry-embellished wreath down, after a hungry bear visited her porch

Man in custody linked police search near Salmon Arm

Police have not connected arrest to search at Salmon River Road property

Rogue masseur arrested for sexual assault in Victoria

John Heintzelman, 65, is accused of assaulting a person at his former business, James Bay Massage

Pints & Politics: Liberal leadership candidate Wilkinson stops by Gladstone

BC Liberal Party leadership candidate Andrew Wilkinson made a brief appearance at… Continue reading

Summit will look at Vancouver Island’s economic interests

The Vancouver Island Economic Summit happens Oct. 25-26

NIC instructor describes ‘unprecedented’ astronomical discovery

Gold falling from the sky. While North Island College physics instructor Jennifer… Continue reading

Hey Amazon, the bid’s in the mail: Langford mayor

The City of Langford has officially submitted its bid to become the home of Amazon HQ2.

Most Read