Giving foreign corporations more power than our own citizens wrong

Dear editor,

Re: Brendon Johnson's comments on the China-Canada Foreign Investment Promotion and Protection Agreement (FIPA).

Dear editor,

Re: Brendon Johnson’s comments (record, Jan. 9) on the China-Canada Foreign Investment Promotion and Protection Agreement (FIPA).

He claims the existing Canadian laws are still in effect even under this FIPA, and that “any Chinese … activity in Canada must be subject to Canadian regulations.” Upon further study of the agreement, however, you will notice that it grants China Inc., and other such companies “enclave legal status” with ISDS (Investor-State Dispute Settlement) mechanisms.

ISDS has become more frequent in its use, and because of it Canada ranks sixth on the list of defendants, with over $200 million in awards or settlements that we have already paid or are still on the hook for.

The result of enclave legal status being that any Chinese corporation in Canada has a higher legal standing than every Canadian citizen in Canada, which includes disputing decisions made by provinces, national boards, and so on.

For example, suppose the National Energy Board approves of the Northern Gateway pipeline’s extension into British Columbia, but the province doesn’t. A Chinese company, such as Synopec, can then sue the province of BC, under the Canada-China FIPA.

Can you or I do that? Or any other Canadian company, for that matter? No, we can’t.

Not only that, in court the case is resolved by three lawyers: one appointed by the Canadian company, one appointed by China Inc., and a third approved by both appointed by the World Bank.

There is no limit to the amount of damages rewarded. This means that for all cases, there are three arbitrators/lawyers, with only one from Canada, for a case that is strictly Canadian.

Furthermore, the federal government can cause a case to be either completely public or, conversely, completely private, which means that there could be some lawsuits and no one would know they ever happened.

To give any foreign body more power in your country than your own citizens have, as this and indeed every other FIPA does, is, in and of itself, unconstitutional, and any constitution that says otherwise is not a constitution for the people.

Johnson states that “foreign investment, monitored carefully, can be healthy for an economy”, implying that under this FIPA Chinese investors are monitored carefully. However, upon a closer look at the document, it is seen that foreign investments are not, in fact, monitored carefully.

The investment section of the agreement, once again, gives more power to any Chinese investor or company in Canada than it gives to any regular Canadian citizen.

FIPA and every other (such agreement) should be adjusted until they give less power to any foreign entity than to the current citizens.

Caleb Draper,


Just Posted

Fish farm protest held in Comox

The rally took place on Comox Avenue, concluding at the entry to the BC Seafood Festival

Tales from MusicFest: Women of the Festival

Many sensational female acts at this year’s Vancouver island MusicFest

Washington State man facing murder charges in 1987 killing of Victoria couple

Two counts of aggravated first-degree murder filed against William Talbott II in Snohomish

30 degrees and warmer forecasted with heat wave in B.C.

The weather could stay well into next week, according to Environment Canada

Labour pains: cheap help is hard to find on Vancouver Island

Big Read: high demand for workers, lack of affordable living mean imperfect storm for businesses

REPLAY: B.C. this week in video

In case you missed it, here’s a look at replay-worthy highlights from across the province this week

B.C. NHL prospect expected to make ‘full recovery’ after an incident in Calgary

Jordy Bellerive was injured in a reported house fire Saturday night

BC Lions defensive back Marcell Young levels streaker in home opener

Young hit the fan near one of the 45-yard lines

Police: Taxi driver who hit 8 Moscow pedestrians fell asleep

Two Mexican World Cup fans were among those hit

B.C. VIEWS: Orphans of our urban drug culture neglected again

Child advocate Bernard Richard leaves B.C. with harsh message

From marijuana beer to pot cookies, Canadian companies creating cannabis edibles

Manufacturers think that edibles will do well with users who don’t want to smoke or vape

Privacy lawyer warns against victim blaming in recent sextortion scams

Perpetrators get sexual photos of the victim and threaten to share them with friends and families

QB Jennings leads Lions to 22-10 win over Alouettes

B.C. wins CFL home opener over Montreal

Most Read