LETTER: Quebec election results would have been markedly different under a proportional representation system

Dear editor,

Sometimes there’s nothing better than a practical example to illustrate outcomes and consequences.

If we use the recent elections in Quebec as a measurement of the differences between First Past The Post (FPTP) and Proportional Representation (PR) we can gauge those differences, without interjecting any political biases, just letting the numbers speak for themselves. It might help us all understand further.

On Oct. 1, the CAQ took 74 seats on 1,508,805 votes. The Liberals got 32 seats on 1,000,909 votes. The QS now have 10 seats on 648,975 votes and lastly the PQ scored nine seats on 687,872 votes. A hundred and twenty five seats in all, with the CAQ winning a majority on 39 per cent of the votes.

That’s the way FPTP has always worked.

So how would it have been different under a PR system, using the same 3,846,872 votes?

Well, the CAQ got 39 per cent of the vote, so they would have been awarded 49 seats (down from 74). The Liberals on 26 per cent of the vote would have garnered one more seat at 33. The QS would have more than doubled to 21 seats with 17 per cent of the vote, up from 10. And finally the PQ would get 22 seats, up from nine, with nearly 18 per cent of the vote!

FPTP indicated a clear majority, as 74 seats could not be matched by 32 + 10 +9 working in opposition.

On the other hand, the CAQ’s 49 seats under a PR system would be challenging as 33 + 22 + 21 could unsettle the incumbents, if the parties so chose as they would be representing 2,337,757 voters, albeit some in the centre, left or separatist.

That would never happen, you say, too diverse to work in unison! Well, who knows? Maybe British Columbia will find out. Maybe it won’t.

Tom Collins

Comox

Just Posted

Transitioning back into the world

Courtenay man had been living outdoors before starting Sally Ann program

A cuddle and a coffee: Six Island towns named among Canada’s most cozy

Sidney, Campbell River, Courtenay, Parksville, Tofino and Ucluelet crack Expedia’s top 40

Comox Valley Santa’s Workshop in need of bicycles for youngsters, gifts for teens

Santa’s Workshop, at 464 Puntledge Road (formerly the Red Cross building), is… Continue reading

New Coast Guard radar boosts marine traffic monitoring off B.C. coast

Six radar installations set up for Georgia Strait to Queen Charlotte Strait to Prince Rupert

Liquor store robbery suspect arrested

The Comox Valley RCMP have identified the suspect in relation to the… Continue reading

The fair with 1,000 stories

Tibetan carpets, Ugandan bags and scarves from the Peruvian Andes were among… Continue reading

BC Minister of Agriculture loses stepson to accidental overdose

Lana Popham announces death of her 23-year-old stepson, Dan Sealey

Mid Island Farmers Institute discusses fleece at November meeting

Are you a lover of wool and local fibre? Interested in raising… Continue reading

Comox Valley Nature invites the public to learn about nature photography

Comox Valley Nature is hosting a public lecture on photography. Join Terry… Continue reading

The fair with 1,000 stories

Tibetan carpets, Ugandan bags and scarves from the Peruvian Andes were among… Continue reading

Canadian military’s template for perfect recruits outdated: Vance

Gen. Jonathan Vance, the chief of defence staff says that the military has to change because the very nature of warfare is changing, particularly when it comes to cyber-warfare

‘Toxic’ chosen as the Word of the Year by Oxford Dictionaries

Other top contenders for 2018 include ‘gaslighting’ and ‘techlash’

RCMP bust illegal B.C. cannabis lab

Marijuana may be legal but altering it using chemicals violates the Cannabis Act

Canada defeats Germany 29-10 in repechage, moves step closer to Rugby World Cup

Hong Kong needs a bonus-point win over Canada — scoring four or more tries — while denying the Canadians a bonus point

Most Read