Lumps of coal have feelings, too

Dear editor,
I am writing to inform the Record's readership of the journalistic code of ethics that we should be able to expect our local media to uphold.

Dear editor,

I am writing to inform the Record’s readership of the journalistic code of ethics that we should be able to expect our local media to uphold.

Truthfulness, accuracy, objectivity, impartiality, fairness and public accountability are highly important elements of reporting.

I found these principles sorely lacking in an article printed May 27 2011 entitled “Coal protest ‘disgusting.'”

This brief piece is based solely on the opinions of Cumberland Mayor Fred Bates and Coun. Leslie Baird.

A few individuals attended Empire Days dressed as lumps of coal to raise awareness about Compliance Energy’s coal mine proposal for Baynes sound and the Cumberland area. Bates’ opinion is that these people tried to “ruin” Empire Days by bringing politics into a “public event.”

Regrettably, we have no idea what the thoughts and motivations of the “coal protesters” were, as Record staff did not include any perspectives other than those of two Cumberland politicians.

The “coal protesters” had no voice in this piece, and Mayor Bates was able to slander a few members of his constituency without recourse. How does this fit in with journalistic principles of truthfulness, accuracy, objectivity, impartiality, fairness and public accountability?

Further, Mayor Bates claims that “coal protesters … verbally assaulted Vancouver Island North Conservative MP John Duncan” and stated that the “parade is not about politics.”

I’m sorry, Mayor Bates, but as a politician, politics will follow you wherever you go. It is your duty, as a representative of your electorate, to listen carefully to their values, whether they are dressed as coal lumps or wearing a business suit.

It is every Canadian’s right to speak in person to their mayor, or their local MP. Shame on you for characterizing this as “verbal assault.”

And shame on you, too, Comox Valley Record staff, for not representing more sides of the story on this event.

Moss Dance,


Just Posted

Stolen Victoria vehicle crashes in Black Creek

On Sept. 15, 2018 at approximately 10:45 p.m., the Comox Valley RCMP… Continue reading

Valley Father-daughter duo share a special bond over a kidney

Annual kidney walk is set for Sept. 23 at Simms Park

Courtenay getting a tool library

New facility allows do-it-yourselfers to borrow tools

Pacific white-sided dolphins spotted near Little River Ferry Terminal

A pod of Pacific white-sided dolphins spent the evening of Sept. 13… Continue reading

Comox Valley Men’s Group meets Mondays

Where can men go when they are seeking a non-judgmental forum to… Continue reading

B.C. tent city ‘devastated’ after flash flood

Maple Ridge mayor says that residents shouldn’t have to return to their flooded tents

Work begins to remove cargo from grounded Haida Gwaii barge and fishing lodge

Westcoast Resorts’ Hippa Lodge broke from its moorings and ran aground early this month

Tilray to export cannabis formulation to U.S. for clinical trial

Marijuana remains illegal in most of the U.S.

Court of appeal grants injunction on Taseko’s exploratory drilling in B.C. Interior

The decision provides temporary protection and relief, said Chief Joe Alphonse

Ron Freeman running for seat on Comox council

My name is Ron Freeman and I am excited to put my… Continue reading

Pat McKenna running for a seat on Comox Council

Pat McKenna, who describes service and building community as his passion, is… Continue reading

Volunteer crew ready to build ramps for B.C. amputee

Jean Moulton will soon have an easier time getting in and out of her home.

VIDEO: B.C. tour offers unique underground glimpse of generating station

About 1,250 people expected at sold-out tour on Sunday

Most Read