P3 model misguided and expensive

Public never sees what their tax dollars are paying for

Dear editor,

The recent decision by the Vancouver Island Health Authority (VIHA) to build the new Campbell River and Courtenay hospitals utilizing the Public-Private Partnership (P3) model is misguided and expensive.

Our provincial government has mandated that major projects go through Partnerships BC, despite the fact that there is increasing evidence that this approach does not save taxpayers money nor transfer the ‘risk’ to the private corporations.

Firstly, governments can borrow money to finance capital projects more cheaply than the private sector, so we must now absorb this additional cost. With P3’s much of the profits wind up out-of-province and country in corporate coffers and there is no long term gain for our communities.

Secondly, VIHA has indicated that housekeeping and maintenance services will be privatized and the current staff will be laid off. Contractors are notorious in paying low wages with minimal benefits or worker protections.

If workers attempt to join a union, they are let go with little recourse. The experience with private contractors in health care in the Lower Mainland is that workers are poorly trained in areas such as infection control and the hospital management has no control over employee turnover, which is frequent due to the non-livable wages and benefits.

As well, many workers are forced to juggle multiple jobs to survive, and fatigue sets in. I totally concur with E.A. Foster’s letter to The Record entitled ‘More child poverty on the way.’

B.C. continues to have the highest child poverty rate in the country.

Further, the private contractor is guaranteed their profits for 30 years, regardless of the utilization. A good example is the Golden Ears Bridge in Maple Ridge, which is under-utilized due to tolling, yet the company will continue to reap profits for ‘projected’ usage from the public purse.

The Port Mann bridge project has problems in collecting tolls through misread licence plates. As well, there are no reciprocal agreements with out-of-province jurisdictions, so those motorists cannot be billed, so we pick up the tab again.

The sales mantra of the risk being shifted away from government is a theory that also does not stand up to reality. In cases where there are system problems e.g. flooding, electrical failure, equipment malfunction, the public demands that services be restored as quickly as possible and blames the government if they are not.

The result is that in-house staff must correct the problem or the health facility needs to hire local contractors. If the P3 contractor refuses to take responsibility, it can result in lengthy and costly litigation with corporations and multi-nationals that have very deep pockets and tax write-offs.

What is even more galling is the fact that the public never sees what tax dollars are being spent on. For instance, what contingency clauses are included that can significantly increase expenditures through add-ons.

By way of a real example, if the utilization of hygienic hand cleaner, that is widespread throughout health care facilities, exceeds agreed to levels, what additional costs to maintain/increase this are incurred?

If cleaning levels required for a sterile environment exceed contracted expectations, who picks up the cost and for how much?

There have been problems elsewhere.

The P3 contracts are not made public and the ‘requirement’ for competitive corporate confidentially trumps  any freedom of information. These P3 contracts are more political expediency than due diligence for fiscal prudence and service integrity.

Fred Muzin,



Just Posted

‘LNG, Fracking and the Comox Valley Connection’ – public forum in Courtenay

Wednesday, Feb. 27, 7 p.m. at the Florence Filberg Centre

UPDATE: Police determine no emergency in Friday’s mystery radio appeal for help

Police had asked for help following mysterious signals from somewhere between Comox and Sayward

Comox Valley child gets dream vacation from Make-A-Wish Foundation

Elliot Hunter went to Disneyland and met Lightning McQueen

UPDATED: Two vehicles seen leaving bloody scene of Courtenay shooting

32-year-old victim in stable condition and known to police

Courtenay to host the BC Regionals FireFit Championships

‘Toughest two minutes in sports’ coming to the Comox Valley

VIDEO: Iconic ‘snow cone’ takes shape at B.C. park near Clearwater

Snow cone forming at Wells Gray Provincial Park one that would make Disney’s Queen Elsa proud

Pink Shirt Day a reminder to ‘T.H.I.N.K.’ before posting on social media

‘Be Kind’ message on shirts sold for anti-bullying activities of Wednesday, Feb. 27

A ‘warm embrace’ for grieving parents at funeral of seven young fire victims

Mourners offered love and support to Kawthar Barho, mother of seven children

Indigenous leaders, politicians say Trans Mountain report flawed

The National Energy Board has endorsed an expansion of the Trans Mountain pipeline a second time

B.C. man creates Indigenous colouring book for children

Leon McFadden is working on 11 more books to finish the horoscope series

UPDATE: Reports of rashes prompt closure of all Harrison Hot Springs pools

Public pool available after Fraser Health shut down all five mineral pools until further notice

Legislation to protect B.C. farmland comes into effect

Regulations enhance food security, encourage long-term farming

Have you heard the legend of Shuswaggi, the Shuswap Lake monster?

Witness accounts as old as 1904, and as recent as 2018, place a creature in the lake’s depths

Credit card fraud steals $50,000 from Victoria businesses: police

Crime Reduction Unit investigating several frauds costing several businesses over $50,000

Most Read