Courtenay council spourns early return of ‘not as affordable’ rezoning application

A request to reapply for rezoning of an affordable housing project on Cumberland Road within a year was denied Monday by Courtenay council.

A request by Len Mathot Homes Ltd. to reapply for rezoning of its proposed affordable housing project on Cumberland Road within a year was denied Monday by Courtenay council.

The original proposal to rezone properties at 703, 721 and 745 Cumberland Rd. from industrial to residential use was defeated after the public hearing on Nov. 14. However, by Nov. 21 the City received an amended application from Len Mathot, owner of the development company.

“After careful consideration of the comments received from the neighbours I have amended my development proposal to comply with the current zoning on the neighbouring properties,” wrote Mathot in a letter to the City. “I respectfully request that council permit the submission of a new application for this property.”

The normal wait time for reapplications is one year, but Mathot asked council to waive the rule in this case.

Coun. Starr Winchester was opposed.

“I spoke with three neighbours, including a business, and they felt it was incumbent on the applicant to come and talk to them about his ‘new proposal’ prior to asking council to waive the one-year waiting period,” said Winchester in an e-mail.

She added that neighbours said Mathot had not spoken with them yet, although he said  in his letter to the City he intends to discuss the proposal with them during December.

“If the developer spoke with the neighbours and worked with them, I would be more than willing to look at waiving the waiting period of one year,” Winchester said.

Coun. Jon Amber called the 12 months between reapplications a “cooling-off period,” but noted that the risk of taking a shorter cooloff time fell on the developer. He also mentioned that if defeated, the developer would have 12 months to talk to the surrounding residents.

Coun. Doug Hillian pointed out that the new application changed from 33 proposed units to 12 two-bedroom units, adding that this change was significant, but that he suspected the rental units would each cost more at this size.

Coun. Ronna-Rae Leonard said the proposed project fits within the Official Community Plan and that the reapplication addressed the need of low-income housing for families instead of singles. She agreed the risk fell on the developer and suggested giving him a chance.

“It’s fair to give him the opportunity,” said Leonard.

Coun. Bill Anglin said Mathot seemed to be trying to meet the needs of the neighbours, and said “the bar has not been lowered; it’s been raised,” by the company.

Coun. Manno Theos made a motion to table the issue for 90 days since the reapplication was “hot off the press” after the original was defeated.

This motion was defeated.

Mayor Larry Jangula called the issue “contentious” and “tough.” He said he was concerned about possible noise complaints from new residents of the property, as land surrounding it is zoned for industrial use.

He also said jobs and affordable housing were two major issues during the municipal election, and that if the land remains zoned for industrial use, future jobs are a possibility. While he said low-income housing is important, he said people have questioned how affordable the proposed housing would actually be.

Council needed a two-thirds majority voting in favour to pass the proposal. It was defeated with Leonard, Amber, Anglin and Hillian in favour, and Theos, Winchester and Jangula opposed.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Comox Valley Airport open, operating at reduced hours

Hours of operation will be adapted to coincide with changes to flight schedules during pandemic

Comox Valley’s Coldest Night of the Year walk surpasses fundraising goal

The fundraiser helps raise money and awareness about the issue of homeless.

The time is now: Comox Valley physicians send out message of vigilance

The physicians of the Comox Valley, and other health-care providers are on… Continue reading

Courtenay council grants extension to warming centre

The Connect Warming Centre will continue to operate at 685 Cliffe Ave.… Continue reading

Helping those at risk, one piece of paper at a time through ‘isolation communication’

Simple paper tool during pandemic making its way across Canada thanks to social media.

‘The Office’ star John Krasinski offers Some Good News in trying times

‘The human spirit still found a way to break through and blow us all away’

Comox Valley grocers going extra mile during coronavirus

We have had numerous requests to post a fluid article directing consumers… Continue reading

Walkers, grocery store customers courteous with physical distancing in B.C.

Some cyclists also acknowledge each other and walkers as well on a wide trail

Courtenay Fire Department assists woman escape from home

Pot on stove created smoke in unit on Anderton Avenue

B.C. worker advocate group calls for more sick days, protected medical leave

COVID-19 highlights need for changes to workers legislation: Retail Action Network

Sweet treat helps make workers at Island health care centre feel complete

Girl Guide cookies always in good taste when showing appreciation

New rules issued for B.C. construction projects, work camps for COVID-19

Coastal GasLink, LNG Canada, Trans Mountain and Site C carry on

Order of Canada Vancouver Island musician pens ‘The Ballad of Bonnie Henry’

Qualicum Beach lawyer and saxaphonist Phil Dwyer notes health officer has become a ‘folk hero’

Most Read