Prad trial: Day 6

Crown calls final witness

  • Nov. 29, 2016 6:00 a.m.

Erin Haluschak

Record Staff

A forensic identification expert said cyclist Paul Bally’s bike helmet, jacket and bike were all in “probable contact” with the vehicle belonging to the man facing two charges in relation to the Courtenay school teacher’s death.

Tuesday morning, Charmaine Lee appeared by video and told court she specializes in the identification of physical matching of paint, plastic and polymers, and tested three different pairs of trace evidence to determine a similarity of sources.

The evidence included Bally’s bike helmet to paint shavings, the frame of his bike to grey plastic from the truck and paint smears on the cycling jacket to paint shavings from the hood of the vehicle.

Timothy Prad, 57, is in the sixth day of the eight-day provincial court trial at the Courtenay courthouse. He pleaded not guilty to dangerous driving causing death, and failure to stop at an accident causing bodily harm in the Dec. 15, 2014 incident in which Bally was struck by a southbound vehicle on Highway 19A near Curran Road in Fanny Bay.

Late Tuesday morning, Crown called its final witness to the stand and asked Judge Peter Doherty to re-enter into the initial voir dire – a series of videos created by the Comox Valley RCMP.

The voir dire is an in-trial hearing that is considered a separate hearing from the trial itself – designed to determine an issue separate from the procedure, or admissibility of evidence.

The videos – created about a month after the fatal incident – were made in conjunction with factors determined from the scene reconstructionist, to have a sense of how Prad’s vehicle may have operated on the roadway, testified Const. Jonathan Grabb earlier in the trial.

Crown attorney John Boccabella argued the video is the best way to capture the nature of the road, its curve in the dark and the rain on the evening of the incident without moonlight.

“What is immediately in front of this truck (right) before impact? That’s what’s very important in this case,” he added, prior to presenting case law to Doherty.

Defence lawyer Doug Marion submitted the video should not be considered because it is imperative the court understand the facts tht are known and sworn in.

“There is no direct evidence of the location of the deceased when he was hit … or the speed he was travelling.”

Marion argued the conditions – particularly weather and certain aspects of the truck used in the re-creation – on the night the video was recorded by police do not match the conditions on the night of Bally’s death.

“Crown cannot tell you with any accuracy that they are replicated … the probative value is outweighed by prejudice.”

Doherty will make a decision on the admissibility of the videos Wednesday. The trial is set to conclude this week.

 

Just Posted

Bylaw rescinded after vacation rental owners express concerns

Concerns included a lack of consultation

Get ready for a week of sunshine across Vancouver Island

Environment Canada is forecasting temperatures in the high teens all this week

B.C. students send books to displaced students of Hornby Island school fire

Maple Ridge elementary school teacher says students learned about acts of kindness

North Island Tour De Rock rider Benjamin Leah leads team to Port Hardy

“You don’t have issues and problems when you look at these kids and how much they’re going through.”

Denman Island awash with plastic debris

After 14 years of Community Beach Cleanups, the little Gulf Island of… Continue reading

United loses 3-1 to Mariners

Comox Valley United lost 3-1 to the Mid Isle Mariners in a… Continue reading

Trudeau urges leaders to follow Nelson Mandela’s example at UN tribute

Peace summit in New York marks 100th birthday of former South African president

Senate seats filled in B.C., Saskatchewan

Canada’s newest senators are the first woman to lead the RCMP and a Cree Metis businessman

Newfoundland’s popular ‘merb’ys’ calendar is back

The calendar of burly, bearded mermen posing against scenic backdrops for charity returns

Cap rent increases at inflation rate, B.C. task force recommends

MLAs say drop annual increase that would allow 4.5% rise next year

Nanaimo woman envisions Vancouver Island’s first cat café

Business idea still in early planning stages and hopes to be open next year

School, church, old mining site make Heritage BC’s first ‘watch list’

The list includes sites in need of protection to maintain B.C.’s culture and history

Yowza! Twerk, emoji and facepalm are added to Scrabble dictionary, OK?

Merriam-Webster has announced 300 new words have been added to the spelling game

LGBTQ activists, allies in Victoria counter anti-SOGI protest with rally of their own

Lower Mainland activists plan to protest SOGI on legislature lawn, Sept. 29

Most Read