Prad trial: Final Day

Judge Peter Doherty told court the ruling for the case is set for Feb. 3, 2017.

A roadside memorial for Paul Bally in Fanny Bay.

A roadside memorial for Paul Bally in Fanny Bay.

On the final day of the trial for the Bowser man accused of fatally injuring a Comox Valley cyclist and teacher, court heard there is reasonable belief that Timothy Prad thought he had hit a deer, argued defence lawyer Doug Marion in his closing arguments.

Prad, 56, pleaded not guilty to dangerous driving causing death, and failure to stop at an accident causing bodily harm in the incident in which Paul Bally was struck by a southbound vehicle on Highway 19A near Curran Road in the evening of Dec. 15, 2014.

Marion explained in front of a full courtroom in Courtenay which included both members of the Prad and Bally family sitting in the front row, that Prad’s “post-accident behaviour is consistent with innocence.”

Prad made no attempt to hide the damage to his vehicle, explained Marion, and even drove past the police and sent a text message to his friend Cindy Perry explaining he was involved in an accident and hit a deer. It is these details, he added, which are “not consistent with someone who struck a human being and left them on the side of the ditch.”

Marion spoke to his client’s credibility and that Prad had a reasonable basis to believe what he hit that evening was a deer.

“In his mind it’s the fourth deer he hit. Statistically, 75 per cent of the collisions he’s had have been deer. What Crown is suggesting is that he would have had to be a pretty cold, calculating person.”

In referencing the dangerous driving causing death charge, Marion argued his client was not intoxicated, was not speeding and the speed of the cyclist and the point of impact were not proven.

“At best, it was a momentary lack of attention on a narrow secondary highway not heavily travelled at night in the rain, and the fog lines aren’t clear in the rain … when you consider all that evidence, there is reasonable belief he hit a deer.”

Marion asked provincial court Judge Peter Doherty if he were to convict his client, to consider the lesser offence of dangerous driving causing bodily harm, and not death.

Crown attorney John Boccabella told court to consider Prad’s inconsistencies with evidence he presented both on the stand Wednesday as well as evidence presented in his police interrogation video.

Boccabella told court Prad lied about why he transferred ownership of his truck to his son, along with not telling police he had one beer about half an hour prior to the incident.

“He tells (police) it wasn’t relevant. He told them he had Folgers (coffee). He even told them it was decaf. There is a lack of credibility to not advance the case – the witness is showing clear tendencies to lie, which affects the reliability of evidence,” he said.

“Many of Mr. Prad’s flexible relationship with the truth is to tailor evidence to present himself in a positive light.”

Crown argued that Prad was subjecting himself to willful blindness – a term used in criminal law to refer to the acts of a person who intentionally fails to be informed about matters that would make the person criminally liable.

Prad’s assertion that he saw “something brown” during the moment of impact is not a credible explanation for what happened, said Boccabella.

“There is no brown in court and in the video evidence there’s no brown.”

Boccabella noted the reason Prad didn’t see a “very visible yellow coat up the hood with feet where the driver is sitting get displaced over the side” was due to the fact he was distracted, yet asked to describe the distraction was impossible for the accused.

“There’s no reliable evidence of what that was … Prad has gross inconsistencies on certain points.”

Doherty told court the ruling for the case is set for Feb. 3, 2017.

Outside the courthouse, Paul’s wife Evelyn spoke to media and said the past two weeks have been very long for her family.

“I felt that Boccabella put together the facts and that he has a very good case. I think the judge has a hard decision to make because you have to prove beyond reasonable doubt and it’s (Prad’s) word against Paul’s.

“It was almost two years ago that my life came to a screeching halt and now it’s happening again … to wait until February it’s hard but I understand that the judge wants to make the best decision and it’s important and if he needs that time; that’s what has to be done and he has a hard decision to make.”

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

A man sustained burns to his body near this spot around 3:30 a.m. Tuesday, April 13 in Courtenay. The fire was left of the pathway. The Station youth housing facility and city public works yard are to the right of the trail. Photo by Terry Farrell
Emergency personnel respond to man on fire in wooded area of Courtenay

A man was badly burned in the early morning hours Tuesday in… Continue reading

This 2013 Dodge Ram 1500 was stolen from Black Creek Motors at approximately 2 a.m. Sunday, April 11. Photos via blackcreekmotors.com
VIDEO: Thieves steal truck from Black Creek car lot by towing it away

Have you seen a 2013 Dodge Ram 1500 in your neighbourhood in… Continue reading

Teresa Hedley and a copy of her book, “What’s Not Allowed? A Family Journey with Autism.” Photo supplied
Comox Library recognizes Autism Awareness Month with presentation by local author

April is World Autism Awareness Month, an annual opportunity to increase understanding… Continue reading

Comox council will further look at a troublesome traffic area in the Point Holmes area of the town. Photo submitted
Comox council to look at speed calming measures at Point Holmes

“…We are waiting for a problem to happen if we don’t act.”

A 41-person air task force, including 12 members from 407 Long Range Patrol Squadron at 19 Wing Comox, seized more than $3 million CND worth of cocaine as part of Op Caribbe. Photo by Canadian Armed Forces Operations/Facebook
19 Wing Comox crew involved in three-tonne cocaine seizure worth more than $293 million

12 members from 407 Long Range Patrol Squadron involved in Op Caribbe

Restaurant patrons enjoy the weather on a patio in Vancouver, B.C., Monday, April 5, 2021. The province has restricted indoor dining at all restaurants in B.C. due to a spike in COVID-19 numbers. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jonathan Hayward
B.C.’s COVID-19 indoor dining, drinking ban extending into May

Restaurant association says patio rules to be clarified

Cannabis bought in British Columbia (Ashley Wadhwani/Black Press Media)
Is it time to start thinking about greener ways to package cannabis?

Packaging suppliers are still figuring eco-friendly and affordable packaging options that fit the mandates of Cannabis Regulations

Two men were seen removing red dresses alongside the Island Highway in Oyster Bay. (Submitted photo)
Two men filmed removing red dresses from trees on highway near Ladysmith

Activists hung the dresses to raise awareness for Vancouver Island’s Murdered/Missing Women & Girls

Comox Lake is the drinking water source for the CVRD. Photo supplied
Comox Valley Water Treatment Project nears completion

The Comox Valley Water Treatment Project is more than 85 per cent… Continue reading

B.C. Premier John Horgan speaks at the B.C. legislature. (B.C. government)
Tougher COVID-19 restrictions in B.C., including travel, still ‘on the table’: Horgan

John Horgan says travel restrictions will be discussed Wednesday by the provincial cabinet

RCMP on scene yesterday at the altercation at the trailer park. (Submitted photo)
Violent altercation at Port Hardy trailer park sends one to hospital

Police say man confronted another over airsoft shooting, then was attacked with a weapon

Comox council approved a change in fees for using the Comox Municipal Marina, extending the collection of fees from March 1 to Oct. 31 each year. Black Press file photo
Fee changes, increased costs coming to Comox Municipal Marina

The town will be extending the collection of fees from March 1 to Oct. 31

John Albert Buchanan was found guilty of manslaughter in the 2017 death of Richard Sitar. Pictured here, Buchanan walking to the court in Nanaimo last year. (Karl Yu/News Bulletin)
Six years including time served for Nanaimo man in bludgeoning death

John Albert Buchanan sentenced in B.C. Supreme Court in Nanaimo for death of Richard Sitar

Protesters occupied a road leading to Fairy Creek Watershed near Port Renfrew. (Submitted photo)
B.C. First Nation says logging activist interference not welcome at Fairy Creek

Vancouver Island’s Pacheedaht concerned about increasing polarization over forestry activities

Most Read