LETTER – ICF executive director comments regarding Vancouver Island train service ‘disingenuous’

Dear editor,

In your May 20 issue, ICF executive director Larry Stevenson questions statements made by FORT-VI regarding the recently released government report on the condition of the rail corridor (Debates resume about passenger rail service). His remarks demand a response.

Mr. Stevenson is very familiar with the report and certainly knows it clearly shows in its initial phase a scheduled departure time of 3:16 a.m. from Courtenay, five-hour, 16-minute travel time to Victoria, returning at 10:12 p.m. His reference to shorter travel times would occur only if the rail was upgraded to a phase 2 or 3 scenario, at even higher cost. The report recommends doing so only when ridership warrants it. In fact, the report hints that a train, if one ever returned, could potentially extend only to Nanaimo or Parksville.

The ridership forecast estimates 10-20 people a day boarding from Courtenay, hardly enough to justify 100s of millions of dollars of taxpayer money.

His reference to the many trails the ICF has ‘developed’ is also disingenuous. Most if not all existing trails on the corridor have been constructed by local governments or service groups.

His hope that trails will “continue up and down the entire Island” is misleading. He knows very well that dozens of places along the corridor – bridges, embankments, rock faces, etc. – cannot accommodate both train and trail. Mr. Stevenson has emphatically stated in public that, where a choice must be made between train and trail, there will be no trail.

The report plainly shows the enormous costs required to reinstate train service make no sense. Besides exorbitant reconstruction costs, substantial ongoing operating subsidies would be required to keep it running, a waste of public money.

Unused rail corridors throughout North America are being converted to trails with demonstrated economic benefits. The E&N corridor needs to be open again with a new and better use.

Jim Smiley,


Letter to the Editor

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

85-year-old Comox sprinter competes in worldwide virtual track meet

Toronto was slated to be the host city for the 2020 World… Continue reading

City of Courtenay 2019 annual report available for review

The City of Courtenay has released the draft 2019 Annual Report highlighting… Continue reading

Scaled-down Comox Valley Exhibition set for Aug. 28-30

The Comox Valley Exhibition is a go for 2020. The annual event… Continue reading

Military personnel relocation producing many foreign licence plates in the Comox Valley

Comox Mayor Russ Arnott is asking the public to consider the possible… Continue reading

VIDEO: Otter pups learn to swim at B.C. wildlife rescue facility

Watch Critter Care’s Nathan Wagstaffe help seven young otters go for their first dip

Plane crashes into Nelson supermarket parking lot

Pilot and passenger have minor injuries

Police find used, uncapped needle tied to handrail in Vancouver Island Park

Officers believe the needle was put there with the intent to harm someone

Michael Buble among 13 British Columbians to receive Order of B.C.

Ceremony will be delayed to 2021 due to COVID-19

U.S. border communities feel loss of Canadian tourists, shoppers and friends

Restrictions on non-essential travel across the Canada-U.S. border have been in place since March 2`

Rollout of COVID-19 Alert app faces criticism over accessibility

App requires users to have Apple or Android phones made in the last five years, and a relatively new operating system

Alleged impaired driver sparks small wildfire near Lytton after crash: B.C. RCMP

Good Samaritans prevented the blaze from getting out of control

B.C. First Nation adopts ‘digital twinning’ software to better manage territory

Software allows users to visualize what a mountain might look like if the trees on its slopes were logged

Most Read