LETTER: Proportional representation is only about democratic fairness, not issues

Dear editor,

Re: Proportional representation article paints a rose-coloured picture, Letter, May 1.

I agree with Paul Ellegood that a proportional voting system would not in and of itself resolve any particular political issues.

The proportional representation debate is about (and only about) democratic fairness, and arguments for and against PR should address only this issue. Unfortunately, Mr. Ellegood’s opposition to PR is driven by yet another outside issue: he doesn’t want to see “more Greens in the legislature.” As for his concerns about minority governments, I refer him to Wendy Niven’s letter in the same issue of the Record.

Proportional representation is a non-partisan issue. If party X receives 20 per cent of the vote should they or should they not get 20 per cent the seats? And does it matter if party X is Liberal, NDP, Green or Conservative? It’s not only Greens and NDP you would benefit form PR. Under a proportional voting system Rachel Notley would not now be premier of Alberta and Glen Clark would never have been premier of B.C. Our current voting system is out-dated and distorts the voting process. Eventually everybody gets ripped off.

Erik Taynen


Just Posted

Thursday night jazz wraps for the season this week

To conclude the regular jazz season this Thursday, the Georgia Straight Jazz… Continue reading

UPDATE: Gunshots fired in East Courtenay on Friday night

Comox Valley RCMP officers are investigating after gunshots rang out in East… Continue reading

Police presence in Courtenay neighbourhood

Crime scene tape surrounds large area where Nim Nim Avenue meets Panorama Crescent

Another big Lotto Max ticket sold in Courtenay

Ticket purchased locally for the May 25 draw shared the 6/7+ pot

B.C. to spend $181M to create 200 general practitioner jobs

Jobs will go to new medical school graduates

Federal leaders trade barbs about India trip at press gallery dinner

Justin Trudeau’s infamous trip to India earlier this year was the focus of many of the jabs

B.C. VIEWS: Our poverty reduction plan is already in place

NDP has another promise it needs to appear to keep

WestJet pilot strike averted as parties agree to mediation

Pilots had warned they could go on strike starting May 19

Most Read